Rick Beato - Scott Galloway on how Universities are “failing” students #scottgalloway #education #shorts
The speaker reflects on their own educational journey, highlighting how they were given opportunities despite a low GPA, which led to personal growth and success. They express concern that today's universities, like UCLA with its 9% acceptance rate, no longer provide similar opportunities for average students. The speaker argues that the education system should focus on elevating the majority rather than just the elite, emphasizing that America should offer everyone a chance to succeed, not just the top 1%. They criticize the education industry for losing its public service mission and becoming more like luxury brands, which needs to change.
Key Points:
- Universities should provide opportunities for average students, not just the elite.
- UCLA's acceptance rate is only 9%, highlighting exclusivity.
- Education should focus on elevating the bottom 99%, not just the top 1%.
- The speaker's success story shows the value of giving chances to unremarkable students.
- The education industry should return to its public service roots.
Details:
1. 🎓 College Lessons and Admission
- The segment humorously suggests limited practical academic skills were gained, with a focus on non-academic activities rather than specific academic achievements or skills developed.
- To improve, add examples of academic skills or lessons learned, such as critical thinking, problem-solving, or specific subject knowledge acquired during college.
- Include insights or tips about the college admission process, such as strategies for application success or understanding the importance of extracurricular activities.
- Remove or minimize the focus on personal interests like 'Planet of the Apes' unless directly relevant to the topic, to maintain coherence with the academic focus.
2. 📈 Turning Point and Personal Growth
2.1. 📈 Academic Turnaround
2.2. 📈 Personal Growth
3. 🏫 University Admission Challenges
- Universities are facing capacity issues, limiting their ability to admit students who do not stand out.
- There is a growing concern that only exceptional students are being considered for admission, potentially excluding a broader range of applicants.
- To tackle these challenges, universities could explore expanding online courses or partnerships with community colleges to increase capacity without compromising quality.
- Statistics show that admission rates have declined by 10% over the past five years, emphasizing the competitive nature of the process.
- By focusing on holistic admissions, universities can ensure a more inclusive approach that evaluates a wide array of student qualities and potential.
4. 💡 The American Dream and Opportunity
- The acceptance rate at UCLA this year will be 9%, highlighting the competitive nature of admissions and the limited availability of spots at top universities.
- 99% of children are not in the top 1%, which underscores the significant gap between the average family and the wealthiest, indicating a need for policies that create broader pathways to success.
- America's goal should be to provide opportunities for the bottom 99% to rise, rather than focusing solely on the current top 1%, suggesting a shift towards inclusive growth and development strategies.
5. 👜 Critique of Higher Education Systems
- The higher education industry has shifted focus from public service to becoming more like luxury brands, which needs to be addressed.
- This shift has led to increased tuition fees and exclusivity, distancing education from its original mission of public accessibility.
- Examples include universities investing in extravagant facilities and marketing strategies that resemble those of luxury brands.
- Historical context shows a significant deviation from the traditional role of universities as centers of public knowledge and societal improvement.
- Comparisons with international education systems highlight how other countries maintain a focus on accessibility and public service.