fantano - A Very Special Christmas Song Tier List
Anthony Fantano, known as the internet's music nerd, presents a tiered ranking of Christmas songs. He evaluates various renditions, focusing on their uniqueness and personal impact. For example, he appreciates Shushu's eerie version of 'Frosty the Snowman' for its realistic portrayal of a snowman coming to life, placing it in the S tier. Conversely, he criticizes 'It Was a Masked Christmas' by Jimmy Fallon and others for its unpleasant pandemic reminders, placing it in the F tier. Fantano also discusses the nostalgic elements in Jay's 'A Very 1999 Christmas,' noting its embrace of bygone eras. He critiques the exclusion of a superior version of 'DJ Play a Christmas Song' featuring Kelly Clarkson, showing his attention to detail and preference for quality collaborations.
Key Points:
- Shushu's 'Frosty the Snowman' is praised for its unique, eerie rendition, placed in the S tier.
- 'It Was a Masked Christmas' is criticized for pandemic reminders, placed in the F tier.
- Jay's 'A Very 1999 Christmas' is noted for its nostalgic embrace, placed in the B tier.
- Fantano emphasizes the importance of quality collaborations, criticizing the exclusion of Kelly Clarkson's version.
- The tier list reflects Fantano's personal preferences and detailed critiques of song renditions.
Details:
1. 🎄 Introduction to the Christmas Song Tier List
- Anthony Fantano introduces the annual tiered ranking of the greatest Christmas songs, highlighting his expertise as the internet's most seasonal music nerd.
- The purpose of the tier list is to rank and discuss the most iconic Christmas songs ever written and recorded, providing both entertainment and credible insights.
- Anthony emphasizes his position as the number one Christmas music expert, adding authority to the tier list.
2. 🎅 Santa Claus is Coming to Town Analysis
- Jay Schlatt's rendition of 'Santa Claus is Coming to Town' channels a Frank Sinatra style with a big band background, appealing to fans of vintage music, which could enhance audience engagement by tapping into nostalgia.
- The song humorously emphasizes Santa's omnipresence with lines like 'he sees you when you're sleeping, he knows when you're awake,' blending traditional holiday themes with a slightly unsettling undertone that could spark discussion on its modern-day interpretation.
- The performance is described as 'tried and true,' indicating a faithful adherence to classic interpretations, which may attract listeners who appreciate traditional holiday music renditions.
3. ⛄ Shushu's Frosty the Snowman Review
- Shushu's version of 'Frosty the Snowman' is described as odd and creepy, offering a unique and horrifying presentation of the classic song.
- The rendition is characterized by its unsettling atmosphere, which diverges from the traditional cheerful tone of the song, making it stand out as a fresh interpretation.
- The review humorously imagines a scenario where the snowman and the children who brought him to life would be detained by the CIA or a similar organization, highlighting the absurdity and dark humor in Shushu's interpretation.
- This rendition is appreciated for its ability to provide a fresh and unsettling perspective on a well-known song, suggesting it as the 'truest version' of Frosty, emphasizing the potential chaos and government intervention that would follow such an event.
4. 🎠Masked Christmas by Jimmy Fallon & Friends
- The segment features a collaboration between Jimmy Fallon, Megan Thee Stallion, and Ariana Grande, highlighting a unique blend of comedic and musical talent.
- 'Masked Christmas' is a song that humorously reflects on the experiences of celebrating Christmas during the COVID-19 pandemic, incorporating themes of masking and social distancing.
- The song's reception is mixed, as it evokes memories of the pandemic, which may not be positively received by all audiences.
- The placement of the song in the 'Frow for Fallon' suggests a less favorable reception, possibly due to its association with difficult times.
- The collaboration showcases the artists' ability to address contemporary issues through entertainment, blending humor with a touch of nostalgia.
5. 🎶 Jay's 1999 Christmas Classics
- Jay's rendition of 'Happy Holidays' from his 'A Very 1999 Christmas' project embraces nostalgia, similar to how 'A Christmas Story' film depicts a bygone era.
- The project aims to evoke a sense of nostalgia for a Christmas sound that may not have been typical of 1999 but resonates with those who miss or idealize that era.
- The track 'Happy Holidays' is appreciated for its nostalgic value, even if it presents an idealized version of Christmas.
- The project includes a variety of tracks that collectively aim to recreate the Christmas sound of a past era, appealing to listeners who yearn for the warmth and simplicity of traditional holiday music.
- Audience reception highlights the project's success in evoking personal memories and emotions associated with Christmases of the past.
6. 🎤 Critique of Various Christmas Songs
6.1. Vocal Performance and Tune Preference
6.2. Cultural Sensitivity of 'White Christmas'
6.3. Song Inclusion Critique
6.4. Criticism of Song Selection and Quality
7. 🎧 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
- The segment humorously critiques various Christmas songs, assigning them to different tiers based on personal preference.
- The speaker expresses dissatisfaction with certain song choices, suggesting alternative versions or artists that could have been included.
- There is a playful tone in ranking songs, with some being placed in lower tiers as a form of protest or due to personal dislike.
- The segment concludes with a mention of a '2024 Anthony Fantano greatest Christmas song of all time tier list,' indicating a subjective and humorous take on holiday music rankings.